Back to top

10 Best Eyeshadow Palettes

Whether you have a day of work or a night out on the town ahead of you, no makeup routine is complete without an eyeshadow palette. With different shades to mix and match, the best eyeshadow palettes can enhance your appearance like no other makeup product. If you are in the market for a high-quality eyeshadow palette, we are here to help you out. In this article, we review ten of what we consider to be the best palettes of 2018. Follow along, and soon, you will have all the information you need to buy the best eyeshadow palette for your needs.

Best Eyeshadow Palettes Comparisson Table

No products found.

Product FAQ

1. What Can I Do to Ensure My Eyeshadow Is Safe for My Skin?

When buying eyeshadow, always make sure it uses colorants that have been approved by the FDA. Always do your research, and take special care to examine the ingredients list.

2. What Are Some Ingredients to Avoid?

In order to ensure your safety, you should be sure to avoid aluminum powder, oxychloride, coal tar, formaldehyde, nanoparticles, parabens, thimerosal, and talc. If you are not able to find an ingredients list, you should give the manufacturer a call or check their website.

3. What Are the Safest Eyeshadow Ingredients?

Here are four of the most trustworthy eyeshadow ingredients:

  • Iron oxide
  • Mica
  • Titanium dioxide
  • Zinc oxide

4. Where Can You Buy Eyeshadow Palettes?

You should be able to find eyeshadow palettes in most stores carrying makeup. You can also purchase them online, on sites like Amazon.

5. Does Eyeshadow Ever Expire?

You should always replace your eyeshadow palettes after six to 12 months.

makeup palette

Image CCO via Flickr

How We Reviewed

The following products were reviewed based on the following parameters Features, Pros & Cons, Price, Where to Buy, and Warranty. We chose these five parameters to give you the most comprehensive and least biased review possible. We believe that with this information, you should have no trouble finding the right product. We cover a wide enough breadth of products in our article that there should be something for everyone.

Overall Price Range of This Product (and Similar Products)

These eyeshadow palettes range from $50 to $200. The main price determinants include brand name, ingredients, included accessories, and quantity.

What We Reviewed

  • Urban Decay Naked Heat Palette
  • Too Faced Gingerbread Spice Eye Shadow Palette
  • Anastasia Beverly Hills Soft Glam Palette
  • Bobbi Brown Limited Edition Crystal Drama Eyeshadow Palette
  • NARSissist Wanted Eyeshadow Palette
  • Violet Voss - The Rainbow Eyeshadow Palette
  • Huda Beauty Desert Dusk Eyeshadow Palette
  • Pat McGrath Labs Mothership III Eyeshadow Palette
  • Tropic Eyeshadow Palette
  • Tarte Be A Mermaid & Make Waves Eyeshadow Palette

1. Urban Decay Naked Heat Palette

Features

Urban Decay Naked Heat Palette comes with 0.6 oz of eyeshadow in 12 amber-hued neutrals: Ounce (ivory shimmer), Chaser (light nude matte), Sauced (soft terra-cotta matte), Low Blow (brown matte), Lumbre (copper shimmer with gold pearl shift), He Devil (burnt red matte), Dirty Talk (metallic burnt red), Scorched (deep red metallic with gold micro-shimmer), Cayenne (deep terra-cotta matte), En Fuego (burgundy matte), Ashes (deep reddish-brown matte), Ember (deep metallic copper-burgundy). It comes with a full-sized mirror as well as a double-ended brush.

urban decay

No products found.

PROS

  • Urban Decay Naked Heat's tones have a warm tone and natural appearance
  • It comes with a wide range of mattes, satins, and metallic shadows
  • Its four foil shades can be worn either wet or dry
  • It comes with a brush and a full-sized mirror
  • The packaging is gorgeous, making this one of the best eyeshadow palettes to give as a gift

CONS

  • We could not find any major issues with the Urban Decay Naked Heat Palette. It is one of the best eyeshadow palettes on the market

Warranty

This product does not come with a warranty.

2. Too Faced Gingerbread Spice Eye Shadow Palette

Features

The Too Faced Gingerbread Spice Eye Shadow Palette is a limited edition product. It comes with 18 warm tones in a wide variety of finishes. If that is not impressive enough, it also comes with an enticing gingerbread fragrance. The palette's shades include Sugar Daddy, Spice is Nice, Lookie at My Cookie, Powdered Sugar, Gingerbread, Bake It 'Til You Make It, Gingerbread Latte, Spiked Eggnog, Hot Toddy, Frostbite Me, Spice of Life, OOO Burn!, Spiced Rum, Gumdrop, Figgy Pudding, Reindeer Paws, Warm and Toasty, and Oh, Snap! This palette comes with a mirror included. 

too faced

No products found.

PROS

  • The Too Faced Gingerbread Spice Eye Shadow Palette comes with 18 different shades
  • The palette design is fantastic and unique
  • The gingerbread scent is a nice touch
  • The palette includes a mirror

CONS

  • It would be nice if this palette came with a brush, but it is a relatively minor issue

Warranty

You can request a warranty via customer service.

3. Anastasia Beverly Hills Soft Glam Palette

Features

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Soft Glam Palette is a cruelty-free product that comes with 14 essential, easy-to-blend shades.

These include: Tempera (ultra-matte velvety beige), Glistening: (iridescent gold with a hint of pink reflect), Orange Soda (ultra-matte pastel peach), Rose Pink (rose gold with a soft pink iridescent hue), Sultry (a hybrid satin metallic finish warm chocolate brown), Bronze (metallic gold bronze), Mulberry (ultra-matte mulberry), Dusty Rose (ultra-matte dusty lilac), Fairy (multi-dimensional light gold), Burnt Orange (ultra-matte deep orange), Sienna (ultra-matte earthy brown), Rustic (ultra-matte deep cinnamon brown), Cyprus Umber (ultra-matte dark coffee), and Noir (ultra-matte deep carbon black).

anastasia beverly hills

No products found.

PROS

  • The Anastasia Beverly Hills Soft Glam Palette is a cruelty-free product
  • It comes with 14 different shades
  • Shades are easy to blend
  • There is a large enough variety to accommodate most occasions

CONS

  • We could not find any major flaws with this palette. It is one of the best eyeshadow palettes on the market

Warranty

You can request a warranty via customer service.

4. Bobbi Brown Limited Edition Crystal Drama Eyeshadow Palette

Features

The Bobbi Brown Limited Edition Crystal Drama Eyeshadow Palette containing 12 soft matte, shimmering, glittering, and metallic shadows. These include Porcelain (soft pink-white), Beach Pink (soft pink shimmer), Moonlight Silver (silver-white shimmer), Pink Lily (soft lilac shimmer), Dusty Lilac (pale pink-mauve), Eggplant (deep purple), Cognac (shimmering deep plum), Twilight Pink (soft pink-rose shimmer), Rose Gold (golden pink), Tiger's Eye (copper shimmer), Toast (toasted peach), and Candlelight (beige-gold shimmer).

bobbi brown

No products found.

PROS

  • These 12 shades complement one another fantastically
  • The gorgeous packaging makes this among the best eyeshadow palettes to give as a gift

CONS

  • The glittery appearance of these shades may be a bit ostentatious for some

Warranty

You can request a warranty via customer service.

5. NARSissist Wanted Eyeshadow Palette

Features

The NARSissist Wanted Eyeshadow Palette is a chic product made in Canada that includes 12 popular shades (1.4g of each). Its wide variety of shades include Biarritza, Satisfaction, Delirium, Temptress, Seven Heaven, Shadow Hill, Mendoza, Wicked Game, Shooting Star, La La, Fallen Star, and Coconut Grove.

nars

No products found.

PROS

  • The 12 chosen shades are widely accessible, making this another one of the best eyeshadow palettes to give as a gift, especially to someone you do not know very well
  • The 12 shades complement one another exceptionally well

CONS

  • We could not find any major flaws with this product. It is one of the best eyeshadow palettes on the market

Warranty

You can request a warranty via customer service.

6. Violet Voss - The Rainbow Eyeshadow Palette

Features

The Violet Voss Rainbow Eyeshadow Palette comes with 10 bright and lively shades. Each pan contains 3.2 g of eyeshadow. Its tones include Flamingo (rich pinky red), Peach (dual chrome rusty peach), Buttercup (rich golden gold), Seafoam (seafoam green), Figi (exotic aqua), Royal (rich deep blue), Indigo (true purple), Violet (due-chrome pink pearl), Pearl (sheer iridescent white, and Eclipse (black with glitter). These shades have been infused with jojoba oil for a moisturizing effect.

violet voss

No products found.

PROS

  • Violet Voss Rainbow is one of the best eyeshadow palettes for shoppers on a budget
  • The jojoba oil is a nice addition
  • The colors blend well
  • These shades are incredibly vibrant

CONS

  • This is not the best eyeshadow palette for fans of a more subdued look

Warranty

This product does not come with a warranty.

7. Huda Beauty Desert Dusk Eyeshadow Palette

Features

The Huda Beauty Desert Dusk Eyeshadow Palette, free of both parabens and sulfates, comes with 18 different dynamic shades, one being matte, six being pearl, and three being duo-chrome toppers, all inspired by an Arabian look.

These shades include Blazing, Saffron, Amethyst, Oud, Amber, Eden, Musk, Desert Sand, Turkish Delight, Angelic, Cashmere, Royal, Nefertiti, Blood Moon, Retrograde, Twilight, Celestial, and Cosmo.

huda beauty

No products found.

PROS

  • This eyeshadow palette comes with 18 different shades
  • These shades are paraben and sulfate free

CONS

  • There have been many complaints regarding quality control. Colors can be inconsistent

Warranty

You can request a warranty via customer service.

8. Pat Mcgrath Labs Mothership III Eyeshadow Palette

Features

The Pat McGrath Labs Mothership III Eyeshadow Palette comes with 10 rich and opulent shades to inspire the artist in you. It features a hybrid cream-infused powder formulation for smooth blending and transitions.

Its 10 shades include Skinshow Fever (champagne gold pearl), Black Metal (gunmetal black with silver pearl), Lazarus (warm pinky brown), Deep Shade (dark warm brown), Night Creature (deep magenta), Xtreme Black (ultimate black), Gigabyte (antiqued green gold), Astral Ghost Orchid (white iridescent with pink flash), VR pink (peachy pink with gold pearl), and Blitz Amethyst (deep purple with blue pearl).

pat mcgrath

No products found.

PROS

  • The palette comes with a mirror
  • The 10 shades blend fantastically
  • There is a wide variety of hues, something for everyone
  • It uses a high-quality formulation

CONS

  • This eyeshadow palette costs $$$. It is not the best eyeshadow palette for anyone with a tight budget

Warranty

You can request a warranty via customer service.

9. Tropic Eyeshadow Palette

Features

The Tropic Eyeshadow Palette is a limited edition product with 15 of Natasha's warm shades, which have been specially formulated to last longer than most other eyeshadow palettes on the market.

It features a wide variety of finishes, from matte to metallic.

tropic eyeshadow

No products found.

PROS

  • The shades in this eyeshadow palette last a long time
  • It uses a premium formulation with high-quality ingredients

CONS

  • We did not have any issues with the Tropic Eyeshadow Palette. It is one of the best eyeshadow palettes on the market

Warranty

This product does not have a warranty.

10. Tarte Be A Mermaid & Make Waves Eyeshadow Palette

Features

The Tarte Be A Mermaid & Make Waves Eyeshadow Palette features a unique clamshell case that is sure to turn heads and complement your makeup table.

It comes with 14 different shades, chosen to emphasize transitions and blend smoothly.

tarte

No products found.

PROS

  • There is very little fallout
  • The clamshell case is unique

CONS

  • It is expensive at around $120.
  • The clamshell case looks nice, but it takes up more space than necessary

Warranty

You can request a warranty via customer service.

The Verdict: The Best Eyeshadow Palette

After reviewing these 10 different eyeshadow palettes, we decided that the winner could be none other than the Urban Decay Naked Heat, which sells for $$, making it one of the most affordable options (price rating: $). Its shades are warm and subdued, coming in enough variety to have something for everyone. You cannot go wrong with this eyeshadow palette.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.